NEWS AGGREGATORS: FRIEND OR FOE?
If you're a blogger I'm certain you will have an opinion about news aggregator websites. These are websites that use your headlines or content and, in most cases, provide a link back to your site in return.
Thailand Today is one such site that provides "All Thailand News In One Place". It features headline news from sources such as The Bangkok Post and The Nation, as well as news from a select number of Thailand-based blogs including Bangkok Pundit, My Thai Friend, Phuket Vogue and The Bangkok Bugle.
Amanta Sriwastigul, a spokesperson for Thailand Today which launched in April 2009 tells The Bangkok Bugle: "Our aim is to put together many Thailand related news services to give Thailand fans and professionals a quick overview of what is happening in Thailand. I do believe that we provide added value to our site visitors because it is impossible for most people to search the web for hours and days to find the news they are interested in."
So what about those, and I admit to being one, who aren't totally comfortable with a third-party website openly seeking to make money from external content. Amanta says: "I can understand what you mean by saying that we use your blogs (and other news sources) as our content. But I think this is not true. We just list the headline and the first few words for people to see whether they would like to read the whole article on your site. Even if news sources or blogs publish entire articles by RSS, would we only show the first few words on our side and never publish entire articles and not even substantial parts of articles. The content is on your side, we link to it and send you visitors."
Amanta also says the idea to include blogs as news sources came from a Thailand-based blogger, and adds: "We have never been contacted by a news or blog source asking us to remove the site from our service, but we do receive requests from editors who explicitly ask being incorporated."
Revenue for sites like Thailand Today comes exclusively from Google Adsense, but operating in an entirely different league are sites like Moreover. They charge companies a fee to monitor what's being said about them online.
Moreover was in the news yesterday over suggestions in may sue the UK's Newspaper Licensing Agency (NLA) over the latters attempt to change "web scraping" sites a fee for using the content from regional and local newspapers. The NLA's Commercial Director Andrew Hughes was quoted as saying: “This is not about having a go at bloggers: it’s about large, commercial operations which are scraping the entire content of tens of thousands of websites and creating paid-for services from them."
I know a number of Thailand-based blogs are monitored by companies such as Moreover, and where their clients are featured an alert is raised. In the days before the Internet, revenue for the publisher (in the case of newspapers at least) came from companies such as Moreover physically buying the printed product. Now they're able to access that same information for free but still charge the end-user for it.
So the question for bloggers is, how do you feel about sites that seek to make money from your work? Are you happy with just the publicity and visitors such links generate?










